Welcome to Papa Kelsey's Pizza & Subs
Papa Kelsey's Pizza & Subs, located in Pocatello, ID, is a beloved local eatery known for its mouthwatering sandwiches and freshly made pizzas. Customers rave about the meatball sub and their signature pizza, highlighting the quality of ingredients and delicious flavors. The eatery’s charm is evident from the bustling construction trucks outside, a testament to its popularity among workers seeking hearty meals. With friendly service and a commitment to freshness—dough and sauce are made in-house—Papa Kelsey’s offers an inviting atmosphere and a satisfying dining experience for all who stop by. Perfect for a quick bite or a family meal!
Papa Kelsey's Pizza & Subs: Reviews & Ratings
I come hear every year on my way down to island park. Every year it is delicious. I really recommend the meatball sub and the pizza
One way to look for a great lunch spot is to find the place that has the most construction trucks parked out front! That's ultimately why I chose Papa Kelsey's, and once again the rough necks were right. Good price and darn good sandwiches. Plus some good character behind the counter.
Delicious, fresh food and excellent service! Thank you so much!!
great zza and service, if youre in the area come through. they make the dough and sauce fresh in house
Great place to stop and eat about half a mile from I-15
Great pizza. Really sweet & tasty sauce. I had the Philly steak sub (excellent) and my wife enjoyed her huge chef’s salad. We also got some cheesy garlic bread. Really quick service, too.
My 2 favorite sandwiches. There are the roast beef combo I like to add crispy chicken and Chipotle sauce in it really awesome.. And the Southwest chicken crispy. In love the soup of the tomato basil. You guys should come and enjoy. And check them out. Really good and delicious food.
Oh man! I used to go to the Papa Kelsey's in Twin Falls all of the time. Then my sisters became gluten-free. I haven't been back since. My life hasn't been the same. I went to this location. At my first bite, my childhood came back. It was joyous. The fresh dough brought my innocence back in my life again. It was well worth the food. Zack signing off.
Location
-
840 E Alameda Rd Ste. D, Pocatello, ID 83201, United States Hotline: +1 208-232-6931
Welcome to Papa Kelsey's Pizza & Subs, a hidden gem nestled in Pocatello, Idaho, at 840 E Alameda Rd Ste. D. This beloved eatery has established a loyal following among locals and travelers alike, thanks to its mouthwatering offerings and warm, inviting atmosphere.
Step inside, and you're greeted by the tantalizing aroma of freshly baked dough and simmering sauces, a testament to their emphasis on quality and freshness. In fact, many customers rave about the homemade pizza and subs, with standout dishes like the classic meatball sub and an array of delectable pizzas. Reviewers like Hayes Boswell return year after year, highlighting the consistency and deliciousness of their meals. It's the perfect pitstop for anyone traveling down to Island Park or just enjoying a day out.
What sets Papa Kelsey's apart is not just the food but also the character of the place. Customers like Kevin Holm have noticed that a great lunch spot is often marked by a crowd, and here, the steady flow of construction trucks out front is a testament to their reputation among hardworking locals. Patrons appreciate not only the scrumptious sandwiches and pizzas but also the friendly staff, eager to serve with a smile.
The freshness doesn't stop at the ingredients. Jaren Smith remarks on the homemade dough and sauce, emphasizing the care and attention that goes into every dish. Whether you're grabbing a quick bite after a long drive or sitting down to savor your meal, the taste and quality at Papa Kelsey's will impress. And with excellent service consistently noted by diners like Orla O’Connor, you’re sure to leave with a satisfied palate and a happy heart.
If you're traveling through Pocatello or looking for a new favorite spot, make Papa Kelsey's Pizza & Subs your destination. It’s more than just a meal; it’s a taste of community and craftsmanship. Trust the locals; you won't be disappointed!
To order or learn more, give them a call at +1 208-232-6931. Don't miss out on this delightful dining experience!